Researchers from the Washington University Program in Occupational Therapy,
funded by a grant from the Horses & Humans Research Foundation, recently
completed a breakthrough study on the therapeutic impact of equine therapy for
children with cerebral palsy.
The study
found that hippotherapy, the use of the rhythmic movement of a horse to effect
therapeutic gains, improves both head and trunk stability and upper extremity
function in children with spastic diplegia cerebral
palsy.
"Beliefs
about the positive effects of hippotherapy are strongly held, but not yet fully
supported by objective evidence," reports Tim Shurtleff, occupational therapist
and lead researcher. "We have shown that hippotherapy is a therapeutic tool that
makes a measurable and visible difference in basic skills that form the
foundation of most functional activities of everyday
life."
The
year-long study primarily involved measuring stability changes in children with
cerebral palsy after 12 weeks of hippotherapy treatments. The team used a
motorized barrel and Video Motion Capture to challenge and measure the changes
in motor control that might have been learned on a
horse.
Molly
Sweeney, President of the Horses & Humans Research Foundation, was most
impressed that children actually sustained the benefits of hippotherapy for
several months after their riding sessions stopped. "The subjects were
incorporating improvements from hippotherapy into their daily life," says
Sweeney. "They actually maintained a continuum of measurable improvement-better
head and trunk stability and improved control of their arms as they reach-even
months after their hippotherapy sessions ended. That was a really exciting
revelation for us!"
Shurtleff, on the other hand, was most surprised at the
magnitude of the "effect sizes", a statistic that compares results of
interventions across different types of experiments. "It is often difficult to
say that statistical significance is equal to clinical significance. With effect
sizes this large, the changes are visible to casual observation and likely
indicative of clinical change."
"These
findings will go a long way in getting hippotherapy the recognition it
deserves," says KC Henry, Executive Director of the Horses & Humans Research
Foundation. "TheWashington University project is our first funded project,
and has set an impressive standard, with their rigorously developed research
design leading to impactful objective results. We were thrilled to have solid
evidence substantiating what so many therapists already
believed."
The
research team plans to follow up this study by conducting a randomized clinical
trial (RCT) of hippotherapy. "A RCT is the gold standard for evidence of medical
treatment efficacy. If we can pull of a successful RCT, the efficacy of
hippotherapy will no longer be in question," says
Shurtleff.
The
changes observed by the Washington University team were confirmed by anecdotal
evidence from families of subjects. "One mother told me that her five year old
son no longer hangs out at the edge of the playground watching when the other
kids are climbing the slide and playing on the equipment," says Shurtleff. "He
was always too unstable and afraid of falling. After his 12 week hippotherapy
intervention he now climbs up the slide and plays more on the equipment than
before. Without any urging from anyone, he just started doing
it."
"Many
people in the equine industry know that the movement of the horse is therapeutic
because they experience it themselves both in their physical and their
psychological health," says Shurtleff. Thus, many choose to donate money to and
support hippotherapy/therapeutic riding centers. Shurtleff encourages them to
look beyond that end. "Their money might be better leveraged to donate to
research to develop more evidence of the efficacy of hippotherapy," he
continues. "Then, insurance companies will no longer be able to credibly deny
coverage. Their money may become a catalyst for much more money to become
available for therapy for kids who need it than if it is only spent once to
support one child or one center."
"This is
a therapy tool that makes a difference," concludes Shurtleff. "While it is fun,
it is not recreation. It is therapy disguised as fun."