|
Most
of us enjoy the company of horse friends - people who love horses, who
understand and encourage us. So it’s natural to want support from them. And,
truth be known, our peers exert a lot of pressure on us, much as they did in
high school.
Attend
a clinic and listen to the people in the stands. Most are trying to learn. But
others are trying to convince themselves (and whoever will listen) that they are
right. In fact, they don’t know if they are on the right track. So they’re
lobbying for their position and then taking a poll, hoping for reinforcement.
We
all want to be be right. The problem is that discovering or learning “right” is
hard work, so “herd think” often takes the place of real knowledge. If enough
people agree, popular opinion is presumed to be truth.
Recall
myths the horse world once accepted as true — “All horses need oats,” “Don’t let
the horse know you’re afraid or he’ll take advantage of you,” “Feeding treats
will teach a horse to bite.” Those bywords became accepted because they were
repeated so often.
I’ve
been aware of this phenomena for years, mostly because I don’t fit into herd
think easily. I’m not contrary. I just tend to look through a different lens —
and I see a different picture. I’m always amazed at how artists notice what a
less visually oriented person misses. I’m not an artist, but I have my own brand
of insight. And, because I know there’s often more than one “right” way, I’m
less threatened by not fitting smoothly into the group
think.
But
it makes situations awkward, particularly when it comes to talking about horses
or training. When I met John Lyons (about 1987) and talked with people who
started training his way, they were frustrated. They were thrilled that the
training worked, but they were disheartened by friends who insisted they were
going to get themselves killed by using only a snaffle bit, or by teaching a
horse to drop his head (after all, they reasoned, when a horse drops his head,
he’s preparing to buck). In addition, John advocated that with the right help,
they could train their own horse. It was definitely threatening to people who
had convinced themselves that only horse trainers could
train.
Fast
forward to 2009 where John and many other trainers have done a great job of
changing that older mindset. Ordinary people are realizing that every ride
trains a horse, and even if they send a horse to a trainer for a few months,
it’s up to them to maintain his training when he comes home. Non-pros are
adopting mustangs and competing them successfully, and lots of everyday riders
pack up on weekends to go camping with their horses. It’s mainstream now to know
that asking a horse to drop his head is one way to help him to calm down. The
herd think of 2009 is different from the herd think of
1987.
But
people haven’t changed. As I consult with trainers and other professionals in
the horse industry, I hear their frustration. They feel pressed to deliver the
new herd think service, whether it’s bitless bridles and treeless saddles, this
training method, or that shoeing method. As always, there’s tension between
doing what they know and doing what is popular.
I
assure them that tension can be a good thing. We should consider why we do
something, especially when it comes to training.
Usually,
the more easily someone feels threatened, the more important herd think is to
him or her. It happens in all areas of life, not just horses. I like to
encourage trainers and others to listen to it — evaluate if there’s a better way
to do what you’re doing — but don’t let it push you
around.
Lots
of techniques we term inappropriate today were all the rage once. And many of
the trainers who adopted them tell me they had reservations the first time they
did it. But eventually they let herd think convince them (especially when pushed
by clients who threatened to go to a trainer down the road). Bitting techniques,
such as tying a horse’s head around to the side, come to mind. Years later, the
tide of herd think changed, and that training practice has fallen out of
favor.
It’s
hard to take your own path. But you don’t have to be like everyone else. Ansel
Adams became famous for his black and white photography of nature. He resisted
the trend to include people in his photos or to use vibrant color. Appealing to
the masses wasn’t his purpose. As a result, he saw what others weren’t looking
at. And photography is the better for his not being bullied by herd
think.
If
you decide to go your own way, don’t feel you have to convince others. You don’t
have to change their thinking. Just do what you believe is right.
Other
people don’t necessarily know what’s best for you, your family, your business,
or your horse. If you’re trying to make it in a business, be the best at that
service. Don’t try to be like everyone else. They’re not all making it. Great
people often do their own thing.
|